Saturday, November 25, 2006

In the name of justice


I was going through the update page on IMDB, when I encountered this piece of news. Read on-
"Chinese Movie Pirate Sentenced to Life
In what may be the stiffest penalty yet for movie piracy, a man in China was sentenced to life imprisonment for reportedly operating the country's biggest bootleg DVD ring. The state-operated Xinhua news agency said that the man, Lin Yuehua, and 11 associates were convicted of producing 30 million bootleg DVDs and VCDs in an unnamed foreign country and smuggling them into China between 2002 and 2005. They were said to be worth $23.9 million. "

Another report- "BEIJING - China sentenced a man to life in jail on Thursday for running what state media called the country's biggest ever pirate film disc smuggling ring.
A court in southern Guangxi region convicted Lin Yuehua and 11 gang members of buying five production units to make DVDs and VCDs, setting them up in a foreign country and smuggling over 30 million bootleg discs into China from 2002 to 2005, the Xinhua news agency reported Lin's pirate smuggling business was the "largest one which has been so far uncovered in China," Xinhua said. The bootleg discs were worth about 188 million yuan ($23.9 million), the court said, according to Xinhua. Lin's accomplices received jail sentences of two to 15 years. The report did not name the foreign country where Lin based his bootlegging. The Guangxi region borders on Vietnam. The court verdict came at a time when the United States and European Union are pressuring China to crack down on pirate copiers of films, music, software and other kind of intellectual property. US copyright industry companies claim bootleggers cost them US$2.6 billion in sales in China last year. But on Chinese streets, pirate DVDs can cost as little as US$1, much cheaper than legitimate copies sold in wealthy countries.
Washington has left open the door to taking China to the World Trade Organisation, the Geneva-based world trade watchdog, to demand stricter criminal prosecution of counterfeiters.
Much of China's smuggled trade in counterfeits is out of the country rather than into it.
In 2005, United States customs made 8,000 seizures of pirated goods valued at US$93 million, and this year customs had made more than 14,000 seizures valued at over $156 million, and China was by far the largest source of the fakes, US Secretary of Commerce Carlos Gutierrez said in Beijing last week. Brussels said earlier in the month that faked goods cost the European Union about 500 billion euros (US$644 billion) a year, and two thirds of fakes seized coming into Europe were from China. "

I can understand the need for the authorities to show a strong stance, but a life sentence? Does this sound like justice? Interestingly, you will be hard pressed to find a newspaper which will protest this man's incarceration. A rapist or a murderer sometimes gets off in two years or less, and a bootlegger gets life imprisonment? Interestingly, a recent scientific and statistical study came out which disproved the claims of the Studios that they were losing out on so much money and proved their numbers to be highly exaggerated.

4 Comments:

Blogger Arkava said...

Justice is blind.
Amen.

2:26 PM  
Blogger Aditya Saraogi said...

somehow i do not believe that the punishment doled out was out of place. Rapists and murders get away becoz they probably have lot of influence. I am sure that this guy also must have had been on the loose for quite some time, bribing the police....The audacity of the crime is huge...

8:38 PM  
Blogger Rohan said...

I'm not quite sure I follow what you mean, Aditya. Do you mean to say that since rapists and murders (sic) get away, this guy gets the fall for lack of justice elsewhere? Isn't justice mean't to be qualitative, not quantitative?

Whether this guy deserved the level of punishment metted out to him, I don't know. By definition, justice is authoritative and, well, judgemental. China has turned a blind eye to piracy from its shores for so long now, it's no joke. Does anybody imagine the monolithic Chinese government is unable to crack down on piraters? Of course not. Fact is, China doesn't give a rat's ass about anybody else. Never has. But here you have a guy who smuggled INTO China... and earned the ire of the, well, Mandarins.

If anything, this shows the double standards prevalent in Beijing. My boys pirate stuff and take it across the border... good boy! Here, take another Tibetan village to pillage..

but smuggle into my borders... and you're a sitting Peking Duck.

10:26 PM  
Blogger Tamal said...

Wonders never cease.I wonder if that same sense of justice prevails when you rent films? I am strangely reminded of National Geographic Magazines. Perhaps now you do not think the punishment doled out was all that justified?? Or are we still suffering from a mild case of double standards?

11:02 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home

Locations of visitors to this 

page
View My Stats